• 1 Post
  • 180 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 13th, 2023

help-circle





  • Is it a simple error that OpenAI has yet to address

    Since even their own creators can’t understand or control LLMs at that level of granularity, that seems to go without saying. Although calling it an “error” implies that there’s some criterion for defining correct behavior, which no one has yet agreed on.

    or has someone named David Mayer taken steps to remove his digital footprint

    Sure—someone gained a level of control over ChatGPT beyond that of its own developers, and used that power to prevent it from inventing gossip about himself. (ChatGPT output isn’t even a digital footprint, it’s a digital hallucination.)

    A quick Google search of the name leads to results about British adventurer and environmentalist David Mayer de Rothschild…

    Oh, FFS.


  • It’s to be expected that an industry would want to study the safety of its own products—although it could point to the need for more independent research. What is a cause for concern is this:

    Another study published in Scientific American found that meta-analyses by industry employees were 22 times less likely to have negative statements about a drug than those run by unaffiliated researchers.

    That does suggest that the meta-analyses (as opposed to primary studies) are being used more for marketing than for product improvement.


  • Enshittification is defined as the gradual deterioration of a service or product brought about by a reduction in the quality of service provided, especially of an online platform, and as a consequence of profit-seeking.

    I think that’s overly broad in comparison to Doctorow’s original meaning (which they also cite in the article). The critical element missing from their definition is that the enshittified product/service never had a viable business model to begin with: it uses the hype cycle to sell users and investors on an unsustainable mirage before inevitably collapsing.



  • the tech community keeps waiting for everyday people to take the baton of self-hosting. They never will—because the effort and cost of maintaining self-hosted services far exceeds the skill and interest of the audience.

    The same argument could have been used a century ago to claim that everyday people would never switch from trains to private cars, because the effort and cost of maintaining a car exceeds the skill and interest of most travelers. That may have been true at one point, and may be true again in the future—but it’s contingent on changing circumstances, not a categorical truth.









  • There is one thing I would find genuinely useful that seems within its current capabilities. I’d like to be able to give an AI a summary of my current knowledge on a subject, along with a batch of papers or articles, and have it give me one or more of the following:

    • A summary of the papers omitting the stuff I already know

    • A summary of any prerequisite background info I don’t already know, but isn’t in the papers

    • A summary of all the points on which the papers are in agreement

    • A summary of any points where the papers are in contention.